NANA DISABILITY CASES: WHY “NOT ATTRIBUTABLE” DOESN’T MEAN NO PENSION

952
★★★★★
DISABILITY
Join WhatsApp
Join Now
Join Telegram
Join Now

Source: SC

Many soldiers see the word “NANA” on their Medical Board papers and lose hope. Some even stop their pension claim. This guide explains in simple words what NANA means, and why it is not always the end of your claim.

What Does NANA Mean?

NANA means “Neither Attributable to Nor Aggravated by” military service. When a Medical Board writes NANA, it is saying your illness or injury has no link with your service, and your service did not make it worse.

NANA Does Not Always Mean No Pension

A NANA finding means you may not get disability pension. But you may still have other options. It depends on how you left service.

Case 1: You Were Invalided Out

If you were medically unfit and had to leave service early, you may get Invalid Pension, even if your disability is NANA. Invalid Pension can also apply if your disability is linked to service but is assessed at less than 20%.

Earlier, you needed at least 10 years of qualifying service for Invalid Pension. A government letter dated 16.07.2020 removed this 10-year rule. The letter says it applies to personnel who were in service on or after 04.01.2019. But several Armed Forces Tribunal benches and High Courts, including the Punjab and Haryana High Court, have said this cut-off date is arbitrary and have granted Invalid Pension to people who left service earlier. The government may still contest such claims, so check your case carefully.

Case 2: You Retired Normally After Full Service

This is a very common case. Many soldiers complete their full service and retire on superannuation or on completion of their tenure. Many of them leave in a low medical category with a disability of 20% or more. Even then, the Medical Board writes NANA, and they get no disability pension.

Under the pension rules of the Army, Navy and Air Force, a person who retires normally can get disability pension if two things are true:

  1. The disability is attributable to or aggravated by military service.
  2. The disability is assessed at 20% or more. No disability element is paid below 20%.

So the NANA label is the main hurdle. If that label is wrong, your pension can be unlocked. If you get disability pension, the Supreme Court, in Union of India v. Ram Avtar (2014), has allowed rounding off of the disability percentage (for example, 20% to 50%).

Can a NANA Finding Be Challenged?

Yes. The Supreme Court has held that a Medical Board must give clear reasons when it calls a disease NANA. A bare opinion without causes is not enough. In Bijender Singh v. Union of India (2025) and Rajumon T.M. v. Union of India (2025), the Supreme Court said the Board must explain its opinion and the burden to prove NANA is on the military, not on the soldier. The Delhi High Court has applied this in many 2026 judgments, including cases of personnel who retired normally or left in low medical category.

What About “Sound Health at Entry”?

In Dharamvir Singh v. Union of India (2013), the Supreme Court said that if no disease was recorded when you joined, you are presumed to have been healthy at entry. A disease that appears later is presumed to be linked to service, unless the Board gives proper reasons. The department argues that this presumption is weaker under the 2008 rules. But the Delhi High Court, in Union of India v. Col. Balbir Singh (Retd.), has held that even under the 2008 rules the military must still prove the link, with reasons. Which set of rules applies to you depends on your date of release.

Weak Reasons Often Used for NANA

Boards often write:

  • “Lifestyle disease,” without saying which lifestyle habit caused it
  • “Onset at a peace station,” as if peace postings cause no stress
  • “Constitutional,” with no explanation

The Delhi High Court has held that “onset in peace station” alone is not a valid ground for NANA, and that calling a disease a “lifestyle disorder” without causes is not enough. The Bombay High Court has taken a similar view in 2026.

What Should You Do?

  1. Check how you left service: invalided out, or normal retirement.
  2. Check your disability percentage. For disability pension, it should be 20% or more.
  3. Get a copy of your full Release or Invalidating Medical Board papers.
  4. See if the NANA finding has real, specific reasons or only a one-line opinion.
  5. If you were invalided out, also check your eligibility for Invalid Pension.
  6. Cases like these are usually taken to the Armed Forces Tribunal (AFT), and appeals go to the High Court and Supreme Court.

Need Help? Contact Our Team

Have you received a NANA classification, and is your disability 20% or more?

If you also have pensionable service, contact us. Our team will check your case. If it is strong, we will fight it with you.

💬 WhatsApp Us: 88826 52865

Tap the button and press send.

This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Every case depends on its own facts.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: What does NANA mean?

A1: NANA means “Neither Attributable to Nor Aggravated by” military service. The Medical Board says your illness is not linked to your service.

Q2: Does a NANA finding mean I get no pension at all?

A2: Not always. If you were invalided out, you may get Invalid Pension. If you retired normally, the NANA finding itself can be challenged.

Q3: Can a NANA finding itself be challenged?

A3: Yes. Courts have held that a bare, unreasoned NANA conclusion, without proper evidence-based reasoning, is not legally sufficient to deny disability pension.

Q4: I retired after full service with 20% or more disability, but got NANA. Can I still claim?

A4: Yes, you may. Normal retirees with a disability of 20% or more can get disability pension if the disability is attributable to or aggravated by service. A NANA finding without proper reasons can be challenged.

Q5: Can a NANA finding be challenged?

A5: Yes. The Supreme Court has said a Medical Board must give clear reasons, and the burden of proof is on the military. A bare NANA opinion is not enough.

Q6: Is “peace station” or “lifestyle disease” a valid reason for NANA?

A6: Not on its own. Courts have said the Board must explain the real cause in your case.

Q7: What is the difference between disability pension and Invalid Pension?

A7: Disability pension is for a disability linked to service and assessed at 20% or more. Invalid Pension is for those invalided out with a NANA disability, or with a service-linked disability below 20%. It is based on years of service.

Q8: I was invalided out before 04.01.2019 with less than 10 years of service. Can I get Invalid Pension?

A8: Possibly. The government letter has a cut-off date, but several tribunals and High Courts have called it arbitrary. Get your case reviewed.

Q8: When should you contact ESM Corner?

A8: If your classification is NANA, your disability is 20% or more, and you have pensionable service, contact our team for a case review.

Want regular updates on pension, legal, and welfare matters for veterans? Join the ESM Corner WhatsApp group.

ESM CORNER LEGAL HELP
★★★★★
We will be happy to hear your thoughts

      Leave a reply

      Recent Posts

      Important Tools

      error: Content is protected !!
      ESM CORNER
      Logo