
In a very important decision, the Delhi High Court has rejected nearly 300 petitions filed by the Ministry of Defence (MoD), which had challenged orders that granted disability pensions to soldiers, This decision was delivered in the case of Union of India & Ors. v. Col. Balbir Singh (Retd.) (Neutral Citation: 2025:DHC:5082-DB). The Court made it clear that our soldiers deserve fair treatment, respect, and financial support, especially when they suffer from health issues because of military service.
What Was the Case About?
The main issue in these cases was whether soldiers who got sick or developed medical conditions during their service—but while posted in peaceful locations—should get disability pensions. The Armed Forces Tribunal (AFT) had earlier said yes, but the Ministry of Defence disagreed and filed petitions in the Delhi High Court.
One example is Col. Balbir Singh, who was commissioned in the Army in 1989 and retired in 2021. While posted in Pune in 2012, he was diagnosed with diabetes. Though he served his full term, his disability pension claim was rejected by the government. The AFT later ruled in his favor, but the MoD challenged that ruling in the High Court.
What Did the Court Say?
The Court, headed by Justice Navin Chawla and Justice Shalinder Kaur, firmly rejected the government’s position. The judges emphasized that granting disability pension is not a matter of charity but a just acknowledgment of the challenges and sacrifices faced by soldiers.
It is not merely a generous gesture, but a fair and rightful recognition of the sacrifices made by soldiers, which often result in disabilities or health conditions developed during their military service.
The Court added that even when soldiers are posted in “peace stations,” they live under stress and pressure. Their job is always demanding, and the risk of sudden deployment or emergencies is always present.
Peace Stations Are Not Stress-Free
The Court pointed out that just because a soldier is not on the battlefield doesn’t mean their job is stress-free. Soldiers are always prepared for emergencies, and the fear of war or conflict never really goes away. This creates constant mental and emotional pressure, which can lead to illnesses like high blood pressure or diabetes.
“Even when not on the front lines, soldiers know that the threat is never far. This creates a constant state of stress.”
So, saying that a soldier doesn’t deserve disability pension just because they got sick in a peaceful area is unfair and incorrect.
Responsibility of Medical Boards
The Court also criticized how the Release Medical Boards (RMBs) handle such cases. It said that RMBs must give proper and clear reasons when they decide a soldier’s illness is not related to military service. Just writing vague comments or copying from old formats is not acceptable.
“The RMB must provide strong and clear reasons for their decisions.”
In short, medical boards need to do their job carefully and respectfully, keeping in mind the tough life that soldiers lead.
Legal Rules Reconfirmed by the Court
- Fit at the Time of Joining: If a soldier was healthy when he joined the army, and later falls sick during service, the illness is considered to be connected to the service unless there is strong proof otherwise.
- Give Benefit of Doubt to the Soldier: If it is not clear whether the illness is related to service or not, the benefit should be given to the soldier.
- Think Liberally, Not Strictly: When making decisions about pensions, the authorities should take a kind and understanding approach, not a narrow or technical one.
- Stress of Service is Real: Even peaceful postings are stressful for soldiers. This can lead to long-term health issues, which must be considered while deciding pension benefits.
Tribunal’s Orders Upheld
The Court also said that the Armed Forces Tribunal (AFT) had made the right decision by giving disability pension to soldiers in these cases. The High Court did not find any strong reason to interfere with the Tribunal’s orders.
“There is no reason to overturn the Tribunal’s decision,” the judges said.
This means the Tribunal’s decision in favor of soldiers will now stand, and the government will have to grant the disability pension to those affected.

What This Judgment Means for Soldiers
This ruling is not just about law—it’s about fairness and respect for our armed forces. Many soldiers get sick or develop health problems after serving for years under difficult conditions. Denying them their rightful pension, just because the illness showed up during a peaceful posting, is both unjust and disrespectful.
The judgment sends a strong message that our soldiers must be treated with dignity, even after they retire. The government and military authorities must follow a fair process and should not make soldiers run around for years to claim their rightful dues.
ALSO READ l WHAT IS ORDINARY FAMILY PENSION (OFP) AND ENHANCED ORDINARY FAMILY PENSION (EOFP)?
Conclusion
The Delhi High Court’s ruling in Col. Balbir Singh’s case marks a significant victory for soldiers throughout the nation. It clearly says that disability pension is a soldier’s right, not a gift. The Court has rightly reminded the government that our soldiers serve under very difficult conditions, and their sacrifices must not be forgotten after they leave the service.
By rejecting the government’s challenges and supporting the decisions of the Armed Forces Tribunal, the High Court has stood up for the dignity, health, and financial security of our military personnel.
For Retired Soldiers Waiting for MoD Action
If you are a retired soldier who is carrying a disability and have already won your case in the AFT, but the Ministry of Defence is still delaying the implementation of the verdict, this judgment is important for you. It clearly shows that the government cannot keep sitting on Tribunal orders, and justice must not be delayed anymore. You have a strong legal backing to demand quick action and compliance from the authorities.
Need Legal Help for Disability Pension?
If you or someone you know is struggling with a disability pension issue, and needs legal help, we have a team of experienced and effective lawyers practicing in different AFTs (Armed Forces Tribunals) across India. We can guide you and fight for your rights.
WhatsApp us at 8882652865 for legal assistance related to disability pension.
ALSO READ I 10 MUST-KNOW BENEFITS AND UPDATES FROM THE DIRECTORATE OF CANTEEN SERVICES IN 2025